New England over Detriot-
DP: I didn't catch much of this game because I was cooking/eating/traveling to the Cowboys game. I will say that when I left the score was 24-17 Detriot and even thought I had picked the Pats at -7, I was completely sure the Pats would come back and cover. Sure enough by the time I took my seat at Cowboy Stadium, the score was 45-24. Such is the state of Detriot. I do think Jim Schwartz is turning things around, but he is taking a lot of losses onto his record. Hopefully, the Lions can have one more good draft and be competitive next year.
TJ: Losing Stafford really hurts the Lions, but it’s hard to imagine they could have scored 45 even with their starting QB. The Patriots just keep winning games, and it’s hard to criticize that, but I still feel like they’re not as good as their record. I think a truly physical team that can get after the passer (like Pitt or Baltimore) will be a huge test for the Pats in the playoffs. I think they’ll cream the Jets on MNF this week, but I wouldn’t make them my superbowl favorite right now.
Saints over Cowboys-
DP: This was a really entertaining game, especially if you aren't a Cowboys fan. A couple of very odd decisions by the Cowboys including a questionable play call on 4th down and deciding to punt the ball instead of trying a 52 yard FG or going for it on 4th down. Lost in the dramatic win is the fact that the Saints aren't playing that well. Reggie Bush almost single handedly gave away the game and the offense is not as prolific as they were last season. They still have poise to win close games, but I think they will struggle to win the South and advance in the play-offs.
TJ: I agree with the Doc, and will state adamantly: Atlanta>New Orleans. The ball bounced New Orleans way quite a bit last season, and they aren’t getting any of the same breaks this year (they were +12 in TO margin last year, they’re -3 this year). Face it, the Vikings should have won the NFC Championship last season. The Saints are good, but they aren’t gonna repeat.
Jets over Bengals-
DP: Given all of the high profile games spread out over the Thanksgiving weekend, the Jets managed to fly under the radar with a work-man-like win over the Bengals on a sleepy Thanksgiving evening. With the demise of the AFC South and West, all of the power is concentrated in the North and East. This will be a very interesting finish with Pitt/Balt and New England/Jets both fighting for Division titles. In each case one team will get a Bye and home field advantage and while the loser will have to win 3 (likely) road games to get to the Superbowl.
TJ: You may have noticed that when I said the Pats would have trouble against aggressive teams that could get after the QB and listed Baltimore and Pitt, I didn’t mention the Jets. That’s because I have no faith in the Jets at all, and am still waiting for them to collapse. The offense is a paper tiger, and the defense has great schemes, but I don’t think they can hold the Pats under 17, which is the maximum the Jets O can score. They can beat weak teams, but they need lucky turnovers to beat the good ones, and that luck won’t last.
Falcons over the Packers-
DP: I watched a lot of this game which was a really hard fought, tight battle. This is one game swung entirely on the fact that Green Bay has almost no ability to run the ball on short distances. I actually liked the Green Bay offense between the 20s much better than the Falcons but they stalled close to the end zone. I don't think this bodes well for the Packers' chances in the playoffs where games are closer and the difference between a TD and FG is much more important. The Falcons continue to be the most consistent team in the NFC (and maybe the NFL), but now go on the road for three winnable games (@Bucs, @Panthers, @Seahawks). If they can win at least 2 out of those 3, I think they will win the NFC South. Meanwhile the Packers are one game behind the Bears and still have tough games @Pats and Giants before a season ending showdown with the Bears.
TJ: Great analysis from the Doc. If the Falcons can secure home-field advantage throughout the playoffs, they’ll probably be my pick to make the Superbowl. However, I think this would be a different game if they’d played it outdoors up north. If the Falcons have to travel to Chicago, Philly, or Green Bay, they may have a lot more trouble winning late in the playoffs. The Green Bay/NE game will be awesome, and the Week 17 showdown with the Bears just got a lot more interesting with Chicago’s win over Philly this week.
Steelers over the Bills-
DP: I didn't watch any part of this game other than the dropped pass in the OT by the Bills. The Steelers were probably lucky to pullout the win, but luck is an important factor in the NFL. You need to catch a couple of breaks each year. Anyway, it sets up a great show down next week with Steelers @ Ravens with the winner likely winning the North.
TJ: The Steelers did everything they could to lose this game, but Buffalo managed to snatch defeat from the jaws of victory. I guess this is a classic case of the Steelers looking ahead (to Baltimore), but I felt like their offense was a bit exposed: they had 429 total yards of offense, but only managed 1 touchdown. They actually only got inside the red zone 1 time (and scored their lone TD). The 4 long FG’s (41, 45, 46, and 48yds) were very impressive for Suisham, but that will not get it done against the Ravens.
Browns over Pathers-
DP: Another game that I paid no attention to. I do have a question for the Juice about the Browns. Why did they start Delhomme over Colt McCoy? It makes no sense? They are not making the playoffs so why not figure out if McCoy is their starting QB of the future?
TJ: McCoy didn’t start because apparently his high ankle sprain was worse than originally thought and they didn’t want to risk further injury. Hopefully, he’ll start next week, because I agree, these games are valuable experience and a chance for him to develop without pressure.
Giants over Jags-
DP: This is kind of the classic Eli Manning game. He and the Giants look like shit all game, but keep scraping and clawing and eventually pull out a win they probably didn't deserve. Like I said, the only good thing you can say about Manning is that he wins a lot. The Giants are now 7-4 and tied with the Eagles. The Jags missed a prime opportunity to take the lead on the AFC South with the Colts and Titans struggling. The AFC South is suddenly wide open with the Colts and Jags at 6-5 and the Texans and Titans at 5-6.
TJ: I don’t like the way the Giants played either, and after losing to Philly last week, they had a lot to prove. I think they’re an inferior team, but I thought that when they won the superbowl, too. The Jags continue to surprise me. I still don’t think they’re any good, but with Tennessee falling apart, they aren’t out of the division race. I still think Indy will pull it together and run away with the division, but the Jags have a legitimate shot. They have road games against all three division rivals coming, plus home games against the Raiders and ‘Skins. They could go 3-2 in those games and win the division over a struggling Indy by tiebreaker. I don’t expect it, but I’d be far from shocked.
Vikings over Redskins-
DP: Is there a team this year that has played more ugly games than the Redskins and Vikings? It’s one thing to be mediocre and rebuilding, it’s another to torture your fans with excruciatingly bad play. For Washington they have played the following stinkers: Dallas 13-7, Rams 16-30, Philly 17-12, Green Bay 16-13, Bears 17-14, Detriot 25-37, Tenn 19-16, and now Minny 17-13. At least against the Eagles they got blown out so their fans could turn off the game. Meanwhile the Vikings had the following turds: New Orleans 9-14, Miami 10-14, Lions 24-10, Dallas 24-21, Arizona 27-24, Chicago 13-27, and now Washington 17-13. Not sure what either fan base has to look forward to next year? Both are older teams that are fading, but neither can really feel they are 'one player away' from winning a Superbowl.
TJ: Doc, I know the quality of play has been poor in many of those games, but are you really complaining about close games and saying you’d rather see blowouts? That being said, watching this game was like watching old people fuck: it was ugly, it took forever, and the balls were oddly shaped. The Vikes need this long nightmare to end, and the ‘Skins can’t hope to catch Philly and NYG.
Texans over Titans-
DP: Of all of my gambling mistakes this weekend, this is the one I feel dumbest about. The Texans weakness is pass defense and the Titans do not have a passing attack to exploit that, especially with a third string QB. The Texans are now back in the AFC South Race. They have the Eagles on Thursday and then the Ravens the week after that. If they can win those two they end with the Titans, Broncos and Jags.
TJ: That’s a big fucking “if,” Doc. I don’t see any way the Texans win both of those games. If they win one, then sweep the last three, they finish 9-7. Still might be enough to sneak into the division lead, since they’d be 4-2 in the division. Sadly, I think we have to count the Titans out. Any chance you’ll see Fisher coaching in Dallas next year, Doc?
Dolphins over Raiders-
DP: Another match-up of mediocre teams. I wish I had known Henne would be back, I probably would have bet on the Dolphins. Miami is now 5-1 on the road and 1-4 at home. Too bad for the Dolphins they have 3 more games at home.
TJ: Neither of these teams has a prayer for the playoffs this season. Have the Raiders decided between Campbell and Gradkowski yet? I mean, Gradkowski played this game, but not well (63.5 QB rating). Seems like a pertinent question heading into next year.
Chiefs over Seahawks-
DP: I was the most excited about this result of all of the weekend games. First of all, my Chief's love has been validated. The Chiefs are clinging to a one game lead over the Chargers, but still have three home games left where they are undefeated (Denver, Tenn, Oakland). That leaves a December 12th show down with the @Chargers for the AFC West. Meanwhile the Seahawks are now 5-6 meaning there is no winning team in the NFC West. The Seaskanks go to Carolina next weekend but also get the Falcons and @Bucs so 7-9 is still in play!
TJ: The Chiefs may still be leading the division, but my money is solidly on the Chargers now. The Chiefs will lose to the Chargers in two weeks and the Rams the week after. The Chargers won’t lose again and will win the division. The Seaskanks and the NFC West are a joke. I hope the Rams win it, just for shits and giggles.
Bears over Eagles-
DP: The Bears are now 8-3 with a quality win so I can no longer dismiss them. They are the classic 'counter-punch' team. They can't dictate the game, but sit back and wait to counter the other team with big plays like long TDs, sacs, and interceptions. They still have the Pats and Jets on the schedule so I am looking at the season finale against the Packers as a likely show down for the NFC North and a possible first round bye. The Eagles are now fight for the NFC East with the Giants but have a much more favorable schedule (Texans, Vikings and Cowboys X2). I don't think any of those teams has the defense to contain Vick like the Bears did so I expect the Eagles to get back on track.
TJ: I was very confused by this result. How the fuck did the Bears get to 8-3? I still like the Pack to win the North, but my money is off the table. I thought the Eagles were better than this. If I liked the Giants at all, I’d take them to win the East, but as it is, I expect the Eagles to roll through the rest of their schedule and win @NYG in week 15 to coast into the playoffs. What they do there is another question, because if they can’t beat the Bears on the road, they’ll have a hell of a time winning in Atlanta . . . especially with all the added pressure on Vick there.
Rams over Broncos-
DP: Normally I wouldn't care about a turd like this one, but the Rams are actually tied for the lead in the Putrid NFC West (that is the official name now). For my dream of a 7-9 Division champ to come true, I also need the Rams to win only 2 more games. Unfortunately, they play the Cardinals next week, but then get the Saints and Chiefs. They end with the 49ers and Seaskanks. I would love for both Seattle and St. Louis to enter the final game 6-9!
TJ: I love the Doc’s dream, but I think it more likely St Louis wins 3 more to finish 8-8 and win the division. The Broncos are garbage. I’m surprised a player hasn’t pulled a Spreewell and choked Josh McDaniels to death yet.
Chargers over Colts-
DP: I am half way to my prediction of 4 losses in a row! I am really only worried about the Titans utter collapse. Next week is the Cowboys and I think they have the offensive balance to really give the Colts trouble. I do want to take this opportunity to take a look back at the Colts amazing run of success. In the age of parity, you can't ignore 7 straight years of 12 wins. The problem for players like Manning is that he makes the players around him look much better than they actually are (name one Colts player who went to another team and was better than they were on the Colts). Manning reads the defense and then passes to the player in the best position to exploit the defense. This way he masks the overall lack of talent on the Colts roster because the players are constantly in a position to make a play and don't have to rely upon their skills. Unfortunately, this deficiency is exposed by quality teams like the Pats and Chargers. The Cowboys have that kind of talent too if they can pull their collective heads out of their collective asses. That being said they are still 4-1 at home and have three home games (Cowboys, Jags, and Titans) and the road games (Titans and Raiders) are also winnable so they still have a chance to go 10-6 and win the AFC South. I am not sure though if another first round exit (to the hands of the Pats/Jets/Ravens/Steelers) would really help the Manning legacy that much. The Colts might really benefit more from a one year meltdown where they can clear out some unproductive players and get a few more high draft picks if they want to regroup and make one more Superbowl run in the Manning Era.
TJ: Hard to argue with the Doc about the Colts, but I think their schedule is too easy to write them off. They’ll finish with 10 or 11 wins, and Manning makes them hard to bet against in the first round. The Chargers have the momentum and the schedule to run the table, and I think they will. Norv will fuck it up in the playoffs, but until then, they’re golden.
49ers over Cardinals-
DP: With the 49ers win, I made it to 8-8 on the weekend which I can live with. The game itself was crap, as expected for the NFC West. San Fran is now 4-7 and one game out of 1st place in the West, but has to face the Packers next. The one real highlight of the game came late in the 4th when cameras caught Derek Anderson with what can best be described as a nervous smile and half-chuckle on the side-line. At the post-game news conference a reporter badgered him about why he would be smiling and laughing after a bad loss. Anderson handled himself well at first then kind of blew up and left abruptly. So where would ESPN go for insight and commentary on the situation? Mr. Matt Millen! He actually gave a very thoughtful reflection on sometimes you hide your pain and embarrassment behind a fake smile. It was kind of a touching moment really and now I fully understand why ESPN hired him. Most studio shows hire really successful former players like Steve Young, Terry Bradshaw, and Howie Long, but no one hires an abject failure to talk about what it’s like to deal with public humiliation on a weekly basis in such a public forum as the NFL. Bravo Matt, you are a true trail blazer! First drafting a wide receiver in the first round for three consecutive years and now this.
TJ: God, the Matt Millen thing is hilarious. But yeah, if I were Anderson, I’d be pissed, too. What the question implies is that he doesn’t give a shit about winning. For any athlete that does care, that’s about the worst insult you can make, because it suggests that he’s a pussy AND that he isn’t a team player. Rough. Too late for the 49ers to make a run, especially with @GB and @San Diego still on the schedule. It’ll be interesting to see if Singletary gets invited back next season!